Friday, June 05, 2009

Thoughts on Last Night's PC Leadership Debate

I enjoyed watching the debate. All the candidates were really strong. They all spoke thoughtfully and the platitude factor was kept to a bare minimum.

Randy Hillier:

Hillier is inspirational. He speaks the truth that others are afraid to talk about. He doesn't take himself too seriously and he is tremendously confident in himself. He is not afraid to say what's on his mind, and he's not afraid tackle tough issues. And his belief in what he says is unmistakable, so much so that he is able to hold his own among his peers, some of whom were clearly coached in the subtleties of debating.

Unfortunately, the crowd treated him with mild amusement, often snickering at his mannerisms. The other candidates treated him kindly but almost like he was some kind of comic relief. I guess despite how inclusive we wish to be, we still can't get past what's on the outside and focus on his ideas.

Which is a shame, because his passion for freedom, justice and democracy is unmatched. His thoughtful argument about the HRC would have brought the crowd to its feet if spoken by any of the other candidates. Instead, there was sporadic half hearted polite clapping.

While Frank Klees almost had me convinced removing section 13 of the human rights code would be the right move instead of killing the commission altogether, Hillier came back with a passionate defense of justice for all and equality in the rule of law as to why the HRC needs to be abolished and real instances of human rights infringements need to fought in the courts with real judges. I am firmly committed to supporting that.

Hillier also showed tremendous insight on a number of issues. On the arts and arts funding he made the statement that the arts flourished well before government funding came along and pilloried the idea that government funding for the arts is vital for it to flourish.

Hillier is the only candidate talking about freedom justice and democracy. It is disheartening that so many pc party members view him as a joke.

Christine Elliott:

I thought Christine Elliot debated well. Her flat tax idea is her most visible and identifiable policy. I believe it is the best tax policy put forth by any of the candidates. She was professional, polished, and articulate. She clearly understands this leadership race will end and made sure she highlighted her fellow candidates' strengths.

Its obvious that Elliott has connections through her husband and has received many endorsements as a result. Those connections brought a lot of professional back room people and she was coached very well.

Elliott makes an excellent point when she says abolishing the HRC would be toxic and almost guarantee another liberal government. Both she and Klees likened it to the faith based school issue from the last campaign in that Liberals would have a field day with it.

Unlike the faith based school issue, abolishing the HRC has support among a cross section of the population including some ndp and liberal supporters. Furthermore, everyone agrees that the HRC is broken and has overstepped its bounds so moving to abolish it won't be the shocker like the faith based schools announcement.

I just don't get a sense of sincerity from Elliott. It's almost like she was holding back on letting her true self come forward. I think she lacks a genuine desire to lead change. Sure, she may want to be leader, but I don't think its because she believes she has a better way to do things. I think she's running simply because she wants to be leader (or perhaps someone else wants her to be leader).

Frank Klees:

Klees definitely has a presence on stage. Although I don't agree with many of his policies, he is a thoughtful man with a fiercely loyal group As Elliott reminded the audience, Klees is a candidate who appreciates and values the people who volunteer to work for his campaigns. I found myself applauding many of the things he said on healthcare and the HRC. He spoke with conviction and wasn't nearly as scripted as Elliott. I believe Klees has genuine desire to make government run more smoothly and not get in the way of people trying to make a living.

His thoughts on Healthcare were consistent with my own, and I liked the way he framed the idea of getting private delivery into the mix. Instead of calling it private healthcare delivery, he referred to it as delivery in the 'Shouldice Model'. Well done. That is an excellent way to refer to it.

I'm sure the Klees team is even more energized after last night's debate.

Tim Hudak:

I can see why Hudak is the preceived front runner. He carries himself as if he were already leader, which has a significant psychological impact. Having policy is one thing. Having the ideas is one thing. Being the embodiment of a leader completes the picture.

His opening and closing statements were well delivered. His answers were thorough and on message. He was well prepared and had pressed his main themes clearly and without ambiguity. I respect that.

I thought he did really well taking shots from Klees and Elliott. His statement 'thou shalt not speak ill of another conservative' deserved the applause it received. We'll see how far that goes.

There were no surprises with Hudak. He performed consistently and met expectations. I wish he would stop referring to 'middle class' values, though. I find the term unfitting for this day and age. I'm sure he was advised to use this keyword, but true equality and inclusiveness has no class, a point highlighted by both Klees and Hillier.

Overall, it was a fruitful debate. I enjoyed being there. I met up with some past aquaintances and made some new ones. It was a pleasure to meet Scott Merrithew and we had our own debate afterward. I look forward to meeting my political friends again on the convention floor.

5 comments:

Simeon (Sam) George Drakich said...

Randy set the bar, the others just limbo.

Scott Merrithew said...

Excellent summary Kirk.
It was a pleasure to meet and chat with you afterwards. Very stimulating conversation.
We'll see what happens.

Rob Cheshire said...

I was on The Auditor Generals Standing Commitee to investigate finance last year and was impressed with Tim Hudak. He is experienced and pensive. But this idea of soft spoken political correctness instead of speaking one's mind, makes the electorate see red.

Randy Hillier has my vote because he is passionate, and ispirational about the truth. He actually encourages people, to be people again with real views, opinions and that being involved matters. The idea that Elliot is leading the pack is about as real as Harper's dog leading. She is a light weight and lacks experience. Rob Cheshire, Windsor
Please join us Friday, June 12th at the Caboto Club - 1:00PM - Hillier Town Hall Windsor.

Anonymous said...

Why can't the Ontario PC party record and upload a video of the debates on their website?

WE Speak said...

PCTV - all three of the debates are posted.