Friday, May 15, 2009

Review of Frank Klees Campaign Site

I present my review of the Frank Klees Campaign Site.

My original campaign review (which did not include the Frank Klees site because it wasn't launched yet) can be found HERE.

You'll recall that I've been scoring the campaign sites on three things: Design & Layout, Content, and Social Networking Presence for a total of 30 points. The latest score sheet can be viewed in pdf format here. I also re-scored the campaigns of Tim Hudak, Christine Elliott, and Randy Hillier.

Design & Layout
The look and feel of the Klees campaign site is well done, and given the intense pressure the team was under to put something together fast, they have done a good job. It's clean, well organized and features a prominent high quality picture of the candidate. It's pretty obvious that the focus of the campaign is Frank Klees. This may seem obvious but the distinction is important. Frank Klees is the brand, and it shows in the design of the site. The navigation bar at the top highlights the major site features. Moving around the site is easy and neat thanks to a good organizational structure. Type is easy to read, and the sections have a natural visual flow.

Design & Layout Score: 6.25 out of 10

Content
The site has all the things you would expect from a campaign site: press releases, events calendar, candidate in action, a section entitled 'Why Frank'. You can follow the campaign from there, as well as on extended social networking sites. The event calendar is updated regularly, as well as the news releases. You can subscribe to RSS feeds on the site be able to follow the campaign without actually visiting the site afterwards, which is great since most people are mobile these days, anyway.

There are a lot of videos showing the candidate in action as well as an audio endorsement from the campaign chair.

I was very pleased to find a section right on the home page entitled 'Policy', but was quickly disappointed when I realized it contained no policy whatsoever. Instead, it contained the following statement:

"Check back with us often to see the latest announcements on Frank’s position on important issues affecting our province."

I've checked back every day since the site launched. Nothing.

Which is a total disappointment given all the things Klees says about how he wants to 'engage' people, and 'energize' the party, and encourage young people to get involved with the political process. Getting involved is a lot more than just showing up at meet and greets. What's the point of getting involved if you have no idea what your candidate stands for?

The other candidates have done a much better job of engaging the membership and energizing. Hudak has an entire site dedicated to discussions and has invited participation from all campaigns. Hillier has a place on his site for people to comment on policy positions and the candidate in general.

Frank Klees is the brand, and as such, the campaign doesn't have a slogan or central message. This makes it difficult to get a sense of what kind of politician Frank Klees is without having to weed through a myriad of videos and other content to figure out wherer he stands. The lack of policy makes the task that much more difficult.

Another element of the site that seems odd is the section entitled 'Frank's Podcasts.' There aren't any. Klees hasn't posted a single message. There is only the aforementioned endorsement from Peter Shurman, and I don't consider that a 'podcast'. It's more like a commercial than a podcast.

Content Score: 3.5 out of 10

Social Networking
Klees scores much better on social networking. He can be followed on twitter and his campaign team posts multiple messages per day. You could almost accuse them of posting too much. For example, there were 18 posts in just two days appealing for memberships. Klees does not personally post his own tweets. He delegates this to staffers and it is obvious.

Klees' facebook page is updated often and contains much of the content from his twitter account, but like his twitter activity, it lacks a personal touch.

The Klees team has done well on the video side by presenting plenty of video snippets from question period and various speeches. I also like the direct personal welcome video on the home page.

As I said before in an earlier post, I have great respect for someone who takes the time to personally contact constituents and others who take the time to contact him. That is an admirable quality missing from many who claim to represent the people. Klees is a MPP who cares about his constituents. He's personable, and has a loyal following. He could really be a force to be reckoned with if he took a some well calculated risks.

Social Networking Score: 9 out of 10

Advice: Klees has been behind throughout much of the campaign. His site was the last to be launched, and he has yet to produce any policy announcements, conceding ground and momentum to his opponents when he should be commanding the field. This isn't encouraging for someone who thinks of himself as the right candidate to be Premier. But it is not too late. It's time to get serious, PDQ. Put out some bold policy positions to turn the tables and put the other candidates on the defensive.

I also recommend that Klees start taking his social networking to heart. This is a case where Klees doesn't match the words with action. In order to engage the membership, you must at least appear to be engaged yourself. Stop delegating social network interaction to staffers

Total Score: 18 out of 30

Summary of latest evaluations:

Hillier: 26.5 out of 30

Hudak: 24.5 out of 30

Elliott: 23.25 out of 30

Klees: 18 out of 30

No comments: