With the Ontario PC Leadership race more than a week old, I thought I would provide everyone with a comprehensive review of the online campaigns.
Why am I doing this?
I believe the success of the online campaign will almost certainly determine the winner. Most people today go to the web first for news, information and the act of simply keeping in touch. It has helped people connect in ways that just weren't possible a short 10 years ago. I believe this to be true no matter what age group.
As much as policy destroyed the party's hopes in the last election, it will be policy that decides its future. As a citizen, this race is a tremendous opportunity to participate and shape the debate. If the contenders are genuinely interested in "engaging" the party faithful, and indeed all citizens who care to participate, then the online campaign is where this will happen.
I devised this review to provide insight into each of the candidate's commitment to driving change, and measure the degree to which the candidate's words about engaging the people match their actions.
I have tried to keep this review as objective as possible. Although I will be evaluating the calibre of content in many ways, I will not evaluate policy positions. Those will come at a later date in a separate post.
A good online campaign will have the website as the hub holding all the parts of an online presence together with links spreading out to other online areas such as YouTube, FaceBook, twitter, etc. It will provide comprehensive policy content as well as frequent updates in terms of campaign buzz and campaign mechanics.
Each campaign will be scored and can earn a maximum of 30 points with each of the following three areas being weighted at 10 points each: Design & Layout, Content, and Social Networking Presence. Full results can be downloaded in pdf format here.
I did not review the parliamentary sites of the candidates because they pertain to the duties as MPP and not as leadership candidate. If the MPP's site is converted to a campaign site, it will then be included in the evaluation. I will attempt to re-evaluate each online campaign every two weeks.
Summary of Results
Frank Klees
Klees' online presence is virtually non-existent. As of this writing he has no campaign site. It was tough to award any points at all but I relented and awarded something to acknowledge the simple fact that there are flickr, facebook and twitter accounts.
As for campaign content, there hasn't been a single policy or platform announcement that I can find. If there are announcements or releases, Team Klees has done a poor job of getting the message out. There is no central campaign message at all. However, while doing research on the online presence, I came accross a post by a blogger who was impressed with the fact that Klees personally contacted him to discuss the campaign. For this, I awarded some value because there's nothing more impressive than a candidate who shows that your opinion is valued, or at least, taken seriously.
On the social networking side of the campaign, Klees scores better. He can be followed on twitter, facebook, and YouTube. However, he loses points for not personally tweeting, or updating his Facebook page. Another disappointment is his lack of YouTube messages. I wonder if Team Klees understands the importance of social networking and the power it has to propel the campaign into the forefront. But they use it instead for official messaging. His followers seem to be doing more for his campaign than Team Klees has been doing and the lack of personal touches leaves his social network presence wanting.
Total Score: 4.25 out of 30, DISMAL
Advice: Mr. Klees needs to get the show on the road. Quickly. The complete lack of anything substantive makes me wonder whether he's serious about leadership at all. It's also possible he may be running just so he can pass support to the ultimate front runner in hopes he'll be highly placed when the dust settles. But if he doesn't get his act together, his support won't be worth much.
Randy Hillier
The overall look and feel of Hillier's site is very impressive. It is the freshest and most visually appealing political site I have ever seen. It is simple in design and yet conveys an atmosphere of excitement and momentum. It makes excellent use of the traditional tory blue colour. It is nicely laid out, well organized, and has an appropriate amount of white space to read content. There are custom graphics everywhere to highlight major site features (e.g. joining, highlighting new members, etc). Important campaign pillars are highlighted right on the home page along with the most recent site updates. It is very easy to navigate and simple in its approach. The individual responsible for this design is to be commended for a beautifully executed site. Hillier has great branding. For example, on his facebook page you can download Hillier branded avatars and badges to use on your own profile pages and blogs.
It is obvious where Hillier stands on issues. His main policy positions are in your face from the get go, so there is no mistaking what Hillier is about. His use of the term 'Common Sense' is splattered throughout various pages along with the words 'freedom, justice, and democracy'. It is easy to learn more about Hilliers policies by simply clicking on the 'Learn More' button where a nice page is displayed to explain Hillier's position. He gets right to the heart of the matter by breaking down each policy directive into simple chunks (The Problem, Randy's Solution, and a Background). It makes it very easy to follow.
Although there is no information about how Randy has voted in the past, there is a section about Randy. Not only does it have a succinct background, it has a section where readers and supporters can leave comments. Moreover, those comments aren't just left on the site dangling, they actually have responses posted by the campaign team. Some commenters have left questions which were then answered by the team. Well done. This is a nice feature.
While I think Hillier's site is an example to follow for other candidates, I was disappointed that I couldn't learn more about Hillier than just his campaign platform. For instance, where does Hillier stand on other issues? What is his position on taxes? How does he think the province can manage increasing healthcare costs? Is there a financial plan? What ideas does Hillier have to create a manufacturing friendly environment? What about corporate tax rates? These are questions that will arise from the campaign. Hopefully, Hillier will expand his campaign platform.
There is also a subscription feature where you can receive campaign updates via email, and I am happy to say I have received my first news release update on the subject of MPAC (you can read my analysis of the announcement here).
While I wanted to give Hillier a perfect '10' on content, I was disappointed that there was no personal video messages or podcasts. These are ideal for keeping in touch with mobile followers.
Hillier's site has an Event page, a Volunteer Page, as well as links to facebook, YouTube, and twitter. You can choose to subscribe to RSS feeds as welll as sign up for email updates. As mentioned earlier, there has already been one campaign policy update sent via email. When I checked out the Event page, I was disappointed to see that no events were scheduled. So following the candidate could be difficult.
His tweets, while very personal, are 'out there'. For example, a recent tweet bragged that Randy can down two bears with one stone. While this may appeal to the rural voters, it leaves us urbanites wondering whether Hillier is just some crazy gun toting hick. It is completely incongruous with his thoughtful announcements on policy and democracy. Hillier's Facebook pages are filled with content by both the supporters and the campaign team carrying much of the content available at his website as well as comments and requests from supporters.
Total Score: 24 out of 30, IMPRESSIVE
Advice: Hillier has done an excellent job with his site, and there isn't a whole lot to complain about. He is dominating on the policy front as well as effectively established his brand. If I was on his campaign, I would advise he post up some personal video messages, record some of his public appearances, and use his tweets more effectively. Other slight changes would be to add a mobile friendly version of the site and increase the frequency of his press releases and campaign updates.
Christine Elliott
Elliott's site has the polish of a professional design. Its use of pastel colours is refreshing and bright and it is well organized with easy to follow menus. Graphics are clear and easy to read with all the major campaign elements accessible from the home page. There is a great little section on the home page featuring all the latest news, videos and events. A campaign follower could easily get the latest from the home page and not have to go any further into the site. The type style is readable with plenty of white space.
The links are arranged in a compartmentalized and organized fashion, very easy to identify and use. The site doesn't display properly in IE6 but I don't fault them for that. It is a bit cumbersome to view with blackberry but displays perfectly on the iPhone and reasonably well on the PocketPC.
While the site may be professionally designed, your expectations quickly fizzle when you realize there is no policy content whatsoever. Unlike Hillier who appears to have an agenda, you are left wondering just what Elliott stands for. There is no policy declaration, nothing on her site to suggest policy announcements are forthcoming, and no where to leave feedback or discuss policy at all.
Elliott's campaign lacks a slogan or central message which coupled with the absence of any policy ideas earns a low score on content. She earns points for having events listed on her site which makes it easy to follow her whereabouts and it is updated regularly. Her speeches are available in a mixture of text and video format with a small amount of audio content. Unlike Hudak and Hillier, there are no discussion boards or input areas from supporters which makes it difficult to interact with the campaign at all, not even a direct message to the candidate. Very disappointing given the expectations when first landing on the site.
Following elliott's campaign is made easy by subscribing to RSS feeds and checking her event schedule. The feeds are updated regularly. While you can follow her campaign on twitter, Elliott does not do any tweeting herself, the few tweets that have been published are obviously written by a staffer but are at least updated regularly. The same goes for her facebook page. Her YouTube videos are adequate enough to get a sense of what the candidate is about, and there is a single personal message on the main site from the candidate addressed directly to the membership.
Total Score: 18 out of 30, ADEQUATE
Advice: Elliott scored high on the design of her site and the social networking presence, but scored almost nothing on content. Cold and formal speeches aren't enough. Elliott needs to establish herself on policy and tone down the 'platitude factor'. The fact her entire campaign lacks any kind of personal touch is noticeable when compared to other candidates. When first landing on the site, I thought it was a bit presumptuous with her in-your-face request to join or donate. It felt like I had come up against a gatekeeper tasked with extracting a 'tax' before I could enter the site. Give us a reason to be on board with your campaign before hitting us up for money.
Start making more personal tweets and contribute to the facebook page instead of delegating these tasks to staffers. While the campaign embraces all the social networking tools, they don't 'get' what it's about. Her facebook pages are updated by the campaign team and lack any kind of personal touch. Her tweets are obviously written and published by a staffer which renders them cold and impersonal.
Elliott is behind what I call a 'campaign firewall' that prevents supporters or followers from contacting her directly. Elliott makes the point several times in various forms that she can be a leader that 'engages' people, but how does she expect to 'engage' anyone when people can't engage her?
To put this campaign in the running, introduce some bold policy positions and get personal.
Tim Hudak
Hudak's campaign boasts two separate websites, one at timhudak.ca, and another at right-here.ca. Both sport the same basic design which aids in identification with the candidate. Both sites lack the professional polish of a designer's touch, but what it lacks in eye candy it more than makes up for in both form and function. The look and feel is utilitarian but carries through to the social networks so at least its consistent. Hudak also has taken the time to create badges so users can brand their blogs, websites and avatars. The site's basic blue colour aids in reinforcing the PC brand, but does so in a subtle way.
Hudak's personal site is well laid out and organized, but Right-here.ca is jam packed and it takes a time to make sense of the page. Sites like these are difficult to spend time on because there's so much going on you aren't sure where to begin. Your eye automatically draws to the centre of the page and you end up unconsciously ignoring all the junk on the sides. The type style is readable but spacing is a problem and the whole page ends up looking like a big mess. That said, after a few minutes on the site your brain begins to decipher the page and you can navigate with some ease.
Both sites display reasonably well, but IE6 again is a problem. Viewing from Blackberry and PocketPC is difficult, the exception being the iPhone which displays both sites well.
On content, Hudak has obviously put his money where his mouth is when he says 'engage'. Right-here.ca is a haven for political discussion. There is a forum with a mix of topics, a centralized area showing the latest tweets, messages from various people, summaries of the week's events, access to blogs, and so on. Discussions are invited by all members, including those about other candidates. Despite this, however, Hudak has made no policy announcements.
His campaign slogan "Right for Ontario" is a double entendre to indicate he is the right choice for leader, but also is a subtle reminder of where his policy preferences will lie. But without actual policy positions to support the slogan, there is no guarantee his campaign direction would match his words.
Following the campaign can be done numerous ways. You can subscribe to RSS feeds and subscribe to the email list and have updates mailed to you. The site boasts an event calendar that shows all the planned events and where. The site is updated daily and there is also something new to look for whether its replies to discussions or new news and information on the campaign. The email list, however, is not updated often so you are left visiting the site to see the latest updates.
Contacting the candidate directly cannot be done from the site, but unlike Elliott, there isn't the sense that a 'firewall' surrounds Hudak. With his site as interactive as it is you are able to participate at any time.
Hudak's approach to social networking is indeed much more 'social' than the other candidates. He tweets frequently, often on a personal level. While other candidates use tweets to announce a new video or event, Hudak clearly 'gets' social networking and tweets on things other than the campaign. It leaves you with a sense that he is truly connected to the people who follow his campaign. Again, this personal level side of the campaign leaves you with a sense that he is open and outside the bubble that often envelops candidates. His Facebook page is also a flurry of activity and contains much of the same content as the tweets that go out several times per day. Hudak has his own YouTube channel and there are many videos including a personal message to the membership that is cross posted on YouTube, his campaign website, and right-here.ca. Although the video is scripted, it's delivered sincerely and introduces themes central to his campaign.
Total Score 21.5 out of 30, IMPRESSIVE
Advice: Like Hillier's, Hudak's campaign has a commanding lead in some areas. The interactivity with the campaign is something that should be emulated, but his lack of policy positions might leave some on the sidelines, unwilling to lend their support. Put out some ideas. Hudak's campaign has taken the first step by stating Hudak is 'Right for Ontario' but doesn't say in what way by coming out with strong policy declarations.
I would love to see a makeover with the website's overall design, but perhaps some minor tweaks with the layout to make it more visually organized would score some points. Overall, Hudak has done an excellent job 'engaging' the membership, which is a common theme among all the candidates. He has taken the lead by tapping all the aspects of the social networking universe and working it with a sincerity that says he 'gets' it.
2 comments:
Hopefully Klees can get a new evaluation once the official leadership site is ready.
No problem Darryl, will do.
I'll be reviewing all the sites every two weeks.
Post a Comment