Well it's time for me to make my bi-annual election prediction. I feel like Wiarton Willy here. Will there be an early election? Does Kirk see his shadow?
Well folks, I've come out of my winter hole, and I say... NO SPRING ELECTION.
I've been right the last three times, will there be a fourth? Don't listen to people like Garth Turner, either. He's been wrong every time. I'd say his election prediction credibility is about zero.
Let's look at the scenario. The liberals are dying for an excuse to go to an election, not because they have a clear direction and proposal for the people of Canada, but because they no longer wish to be accused of sitting on their hands and propping up a government that they profess is taking the country in the opposite direction of what Canadians want (which is why the Tories were elected, Dion?). They also wish to end the farcical tenure of Dion, and an election is the only way to do it.
Unless you're one of those 'retiring' MPs, or one with a safe city riding (like Toronto, Vancouver, or Montreal) you'd be hard pressed to slit your own throat. Stephane Dion is fooling himself if he thinks Afghanistan will win him an election. It won't. Since the Manley report was issued, Dion's opinions have been rendered obsolete. The environment will be a loser for him, too, especially if he goes on about carbon taxes.
No, this election (if there is one) will be about the economy, which is prime Tory territory. They are better equipped to manage the economy than that utopian seeking socialist Liberal Leader. And if the economy is what we go to an election on, the Liberals will most certainly lose. Liberals know that, which is why they will back down from pressing the button (unless they just want to get rid of Dion, in which case they will willingly commit political suicide to do so, but I'm betting Liberal MPs will not commit suicide.
Aside from John McCallum and perhaps Ralph Goodale is there anyone in the Liberal caucus with any street cred on economic policy?
And let's face it, the only way to bring the government down over the economy is on the budget. Do you think the Tories aren't going to put forth another big spending budget? They most certainly are. Some of the things to watch for will be economic development money for Canada's manufacturing, more family friendly policy, eastern economic development agency money, Olympics investment, and, of course, plenty of health and infrastructure based provincial transfers.
The Tories will position themselves well for an election, and they most certainly will outwit, outlast, and outplay hapless Dion. They can control the agenda, the election, the timing, and how, when, and if, they decide to allow themselves to fall.
But what of Duceppe and Layton? With both leaders already professing their desire to bring the government down over Afghanistan, it will be up to Dion in that regard, but the budget is another thing altogether. Another hail mary for Duceppe would ensure this government's survival until the political landscape changes, but with things remaining largely the same since the last go around, I suspect the game will play out the same, that being Duceppe and Layton will come out of the gate early by staking their policy positions before Dion can react, leaving Dion with the final decision as to whether the government lives or falls.
As before, I believe it is in the government's interest to keep Dion as head of the Liberal Party. With him there, major rivals for leadership can work their knives slowly and in secret, leaving Harper to govern until the scheduled 2009 election. I believe this is Harper's end game. And because he's a master strategist, I believe he will get there, which means... no spring election.
And perhaps the most important reason there won't be an election is the fact that people don't want one. They didn't want one before, they don't want one now. Is there any reason to believe that an election now will change parliament in any significant way?
Well, they say that a month is a lifetime in politics. We'll see what happens after the budget.
Are we taking bets this time?
5 comments:
I think you are right, no election. Have you seen how few Liberals are even bothering to show up for question period?
Dion is all talk with his election threats. Your're right, the last thing Dion wants is an election. I think the only Libs who actually want an election are those who want to get the election loss over with so they can replace their loser leader.
Once we're into a campaign, and Canadians get to watch Dion 'speak' to the nation for 30 or so days, undecided voters will flock to the other parties, and many traditional Liberals will just stay home on election day.
I'm just trying to picture a debate between Harper and Dion... what a joke! Most of us just won't understand what Dion says, and those who can actually figure out what he says, will be left shaking their heads.
The Liberals cant go to an election yet as they have no money. The leadership candidates have HUGE debts to pay off before June of this year.
As for Garth, hes been predicting a slow down in the housing market for 20 years and elections every month now in 2007...and hes back at it again.
Methinks he wants to lose, so he can go back out to the private sector to make money. Being an MP isnt the cash cow that he thought it was.
Some liberals want an election, pray for a minority conservative government again and give das boot to Dion and usher Iggy in ASAP.
I say bring it on. Make everything in the house a confidence motion and either watch them sit on their hands for another year OR usher in a possible majority conservative government where they can be a bit more relaxed and not under the constant threat of being brought down.
PM Harper will go in history as the PM with the longest minority government. Thats leadership.
Sitting on your hands saying "we could do it better" but not doing anything about it...thats NOT leadership.
Predicting an election every month like Garth is, well EVENTUALLY hes going to be right....right?
hmmm, perhaps Monty will be revamping the EI rules to aid the mfg industry, seems the ROC is doing ok:
'Jobless rate declines to 5.8 per cent in January
Feb. 8 2008
CTV.ca News Staff
Canada's jobless rate dropped to 5.8 per cent in January as the economy created 46,000 new positions, reports Statistics Canada.'
But didnt you know? The economy is going into the sewer according to Garth...hes usually right? Right?
Stock market has stabelized, housing starts while slowing are still showing signs of strength, Garth in his recent town hall stated to the dozen or so attendees that he supports "sprawl" when a rural resident posed a question to him, and people overall seem somewhat confident in the economy.
But in Garths world the sky is falling....
See what happens when governments dont knee jerk all over the economy ?
Post a Comment