And he's either deliberately trying to stir the pot or he's being obtuse.
To suggest that Ezra Levant's fight with the Human Rights Commission is because he's 'against human rights' is absurd. His assertion that Levant is being hypocritical because of this is also absurd. Isn't free speech one of those basic kind of 'Human Rights'?
First, Levant's case against FFW will be a court case, bound by the rules of evidence and presided over by a real judge, with robes and everything. If Levant's case is successful, it will be because there is precedence in case law, not at the whim of a bureaucrat. What's Kinsella thinking?
Second, Levant's case will be funded by Levant, and is based on (what I assume to be) the idea of damages, or libel. Perhaps he felt FFW caused him some hurt in some way. But the bottom line is that there must be some legal impetus for the case.
On the other hand, the HRC case against Levant is not going to court. It is being 'heard' by a bureaucrat, not a judge or jury, and launched by someone who couldn't get it heard in a real court. It was initiated by someone who will not put up a single penny. It's funded by the taxpayers. To suggest that Levant should answer to the though police should be throwing up red flags for any freedom loving individual, including you WK!
But what Levant is fighting for (on behalf of all citizens), is the protection of free speech and the right of every citizen to make up his or her mind on any issue. He is also fighting against an over reaching government bureaucracy.
No, Levant isn't against human rights. He's against the repression of those rights. Kinsella can see that. He just refuses to admit it.
2 comments:
"Kinsella can see that. He just refuses to admit it".
Bingo! But why does he do this?
There is the right to speak freely; there is also the obligation not to offend your fat ugly mother-in-law who can't cook. Yes, you can freely say to her that she is butt ugly and her potatoes are crunchy. However, you still want to be on good terms with your spouse. You don't say anything negative about your spouse's mother even though you have the right to exercise your free speech.
I have mentioned in other blog comments that I would probably not shove a picture of the Prophet Muhammad in front of a Muslim even though I feel that I have the right to do so. The Muslim is like a mother-in-law who you do not wish to offend (most of the time). Yet, I do feel that I have the right to draw and view Muhammad because I am not a Muslim. For a Muslim to tell me that I cannot draw or view the Prophet Muhammad, I must ask if he owns the copyright to Muhammad's representation.
Warren Kinsella may choose not to offend the Muslim community. That is his choice. Ezra Levant may choose to make comments that offend his figurative mother-in-law and some Muslims. By publishing the cartoons, he has not shown representation of anything that is factually false. He has not told his readership to attack his (figurative) mommy-in-law. He has finally said that he is tired of the crap that is coming from his mother-in-law. Sometimes we need to speak up.
Post a Comment