Tuesday, January 27, 2009

Let's Stop Fooling Ourselves. It's not really a budget, is it'?

How did we get from 'the oppositon is panicking' and 'this government will not go into deficit' to a $34 BILLION deficit in less than 90 days.

Jeez.

They're not even trying to pretend it's a budget anymore. They're calling it a 'stimulus plan' or 'spending plan'. Forget the word 'Budget'. That alone should have us all running for the hills.

I would personally like to thank our 'conservative' government for saddling my 5 year old son with a debt he will have to pay back just so we can all pretend we're doing something constructive. The numbers they are throwing out makes me wish Paul Martin was still the Finance Minister.

Who's panicking now, Steve? Jim?

And here's a question. Every financial manager out there is recommending that people pay down debt, invest carefully, and rethink spending. Why does our national national government see fit to do the exact opposite? Anyone? If overspending and living beyond our means contributed to the credit crunch, how does replicating that behaviour qualify as sober thought? The definition of insanity is to do the same thing over and over again and expect different results.

Have we learned nothing from the last 20 years? This country has been paying through the nose in higher taxes for more than a decade so we can pay down debt left from successive governments (including that other so-called 'conservative' government) and now we see fit to reverse all that work. We paid down $108 Billion since 1995 and some analysts are predicting the deficit could very well hit that number in 5 years.

If anyone finds a lost conservative government out there, could you let me know? It's been a while since I last saw one. I hear they are extremely rare. Don't be fooled though, most conservatives look conservative on the outside, but after careful study of their behaviour, they turn out to be Liberals. Sometimes, they turn out to be old fashioned "Trudeau-Liberals" of the tax and spend variety, the dreaded "Trudeausiris-spendaliscous Liberalis"

I highly doubt that 'stimulating' the economy now is worth the price we'll pay down the road.

7 comments:

wilson said...

'...government will not go into deficit' to a $34 BILLION deficit in less than 90 days.''

the same way oil went from
$143 to $34
in less than 90 days,
while ALL 'experts' were predicting $200 oil.

the same way the IMF (International money 'experts') said Canada would be the only G20 country to NOT go into recession, 90 days ago.

the same way ALL parties in the Oct election predicted NO deficit spending,
and then 2 months later threatened to overthrow the government because they wouldn't spend $30 billion we didn't have, on stimulus.

Where have you been?

Kirk West said...

Wilson,

The point is this:

We aren't actually in a recession. A recession is two consecutive quarters of negative growth. We haven't had a single quarter, yet. Maybe we will report one, but until then, don't tell me we are in a recession.

Canada's GDP rose an anualized 1.3% in the 3rd quarter. Although 4th quarter results are expected to be dismal, they haven't come out yet. And even if it shows negative, it still only counts as one quarter.

My point is, there is no justification for overspending to this magnitude.

$64 Billion over two years? Doesn't that sound a little extreme for a country of 34 Million?

It took us 14 years to pay $108 Billion of debt, and we're going to wipe out more than 50% of that in just 24 months. It's INSANE!!

Kirk West said...

EDIT:

"We're aren't actually in a recession"

I meant to say, "We're arent' technically in a recession, yet".

wilson said...

Wasn't your point that
PMSH should have looked into the future with his known Medium powers,
and told us all that the global economy was going to crash on November 15th, at 10am central time?

Yes, we are increasing the national debt by $64 billion.....but at 1% interest rate. As compared to 4 1/4% just 18 months ago.
Servicing the national debt has dropped by Billions of dollars.
do the math.
Service a $500 B debt at 5%
vs $565 B at 1.5%.
That's why we will be out of deficit in 3-5 years.
Low interest rates plus rebounding commodity prices.

Going into debt to purchase assets is very Conservative.
Bridges, schools, education & retraining are all assets.
These things contribute to the future.
Managing excess is very Conservative,
like selling off or trading buildings that exceed our needs, or freezing public service wages that are 25% higher than private industry wages.

Sometimes, we all have enough knowledge to complain, but not enough knowledge to get real.
That's a Liberal trait.

Kirk West said...

Wilson,

You said: "Wasn't your point that
PMSH should have looked into the future with his known Medium powers,
and told us all that the global economy was going to crash on November 15th, at 10am central time?"

Of course not. but for years, the opposition argued that deficit spending was an evil to be avoided at all costs. Which many of us agree with. To completely reverse course (not with a little deficit, a HUGE one) in such a short time without any rationalization as to why this philosophical transformation took place is to put it mildly, cynical and just plain crap.

After years of arguing small-c conservative values (which apply no matter what the economic conditions) the reversal is astounding.

Af for your other statement:
"Going into debt to purchase assets is very Conservative" is meaningless. Capital expenditures by their nature are not expenses, and therefore don't factor in the deficit, because assets don't go on P/L's.

It's ironic that you should accuse me of not having "enough knowledge" to get real.

"Managing excess is very Conservative". So I should be grateful the deficit isn't $100 Billion?

Regardless of the interest rate, deficit financing is simply spending more than you have now and having to repay it later. A simple truth about government is that they always promise to pay things back but never do.

Here's what's going to happen. In 3-5 years, we'll have another Liberal dynasty (because that's what always happens). They will then accuse the Conservatives of cooking the books and leaving us with twice the debt we were supposed to have. while they 'fight' to get our finances under control they will take all the new revenue they have and pump it in to more social programs and leave a piddly amount to pay down debt.

But by then, we'll be having a mass exodus of retirees clogging our hospitals and stretching the pension plan to its limits. Taxes will go up to account for the shortfall and runaway inflation will prevent us from paying debt at a rate we have become accustomed to.

Bottom Line: High Taxes. No noticeable change in economic activity despite throwing mass amounts of money at anything that moves. And another legacy of Conservatives who became Liberals.

Anonymous said...

$34 BILLION deficit does not get your attention? Of cousre this is about the budget.

Anonymous said...

Just more proof that the ideals that let me like but not always agree with Preston Manning have long since been flushed out of the Canadian Conservative leadership.

It appears that Harper will do or say anything including eating kittens to keep power. God forbid you ever question that single minded drive for power or loss of ideals or the Conbots will jump all over you and rationalize the lies.

Canadian politics has become a pitiful thing when all parties can agree that more debt and pushing heavy obligations on our children is rational and just. My status as a Green is based on my belief that living within our personal and planetary means is paramount to our survival. This budget does not satisfy me as it continues the trend of squandering our future.

Government/personal debt and over consumption caused many of the worlds financial and environment problems and creating more debt to consume more is not the answer. The Conservatives think the insight program is evil because it allows junkies to get their fix in safety, but This "Budget" is just a corporate and personal insight program allowing one last bash of debt and consumption before we get thrown in detox.