Many pundits think Stephane Dion's Carbon Tax Plan is a big policy gamble with undertones of 'brilliance.'
Forget the policy. We all know what happens when governments start talking about big policy ideas. It just translates into bigger government, more taxation, less economic growth. End of story. And if you believe this 'revenue neutrality' proposition, I've got some land on the coast of Florida guranteed to stay dry when the oceans rise.
Pundits think this carbon tax idea is a stroke of brilliance wrapped up in an enigma. The idea is that the Conservatives will be caught like deer in headlights by an unexpected 'shift' in the public's thinking that the government should tax them for their carbon wasting ways. The conservatives, not realizing this, will automatically attack the plan and come off as a bunch of 'climate change deniers' just when public sentiment is turning toward this carbon tax plan. But that's where the pundits are wrong.
We all know what shape our economy is in. If gas prices continue to rise, economic activity will diminish further. And with natural gas prices set to increase by as much as 50% on July 1st, the last thing the public is going to do is vote in favour of higher taxation.
However, if the public buys in to the claim that a carbon tax would be revenue neutral, the Liberals could come out ahead.
Free advice for the Conservatives: You would do well to focus on revenue neutrality as the enemy. If you attack the 'carbon tax plan', you will come off as angry climate change deniers and play right into the Liberal hands. Instead, attack revenue neutrality, make the people believe they will be poor under the Liberals, and you will be tax freedom fighters. 'Power to the people!' That's a positive message that will resonate with voters and be a subtle reminder that under the Liberals, there won't be any power, just taxation.
Now that's a campaign I could 'buy' into.
4 comments:
GM just announced that they are going to shut down the Oshawa truck plant for two months to help reduce the backlog of vehicles. This is in addition to the permanent closure in 2009. The reason, as is well known, is the high gasoline prices that are driving people to more fuel efficient modes of transport.
The airline industry is taking a beating for the same reason. And the impact has yet to hit the aircraft manufacturers and their parts suppliers as yet.
When the Nutty Professor's tax grab scheme is shown to be the job killer that it is, I doubt that the average family will be very anxious to suport it.
lets hope that Dion and his gang of liberal knuckleheads never get the chance to inflict their green shaft on us
Kirk,
I think Dion's plan can be attacked from many fronts...
Of course, the revenue neutrality claim is a complete farce, and open to many assults.
I disagree about not attacking the basic carbon tax plan because of a 'climate denier' label. I still consider myself a climate change 'denier' and am not ready to give up that fight. I don't want to throw away money after a goal that I don't believe in.
Even if Dion's plan were to work, and what better way to reduce carbon pollution than to totally kill the economy like it most certainly will do, is this really a problem? Is the science really settled? Even if it were, is Canada's contribution going to matter in the grand scheme of things. Besides, I believe a little global warming would be a huge net benefit to Canada--bring it on! I'm all for cleaning up the environment, but I'm more concerned with our pollution of lakes, rivers and air particulates.
And how effective will any tax be at reducing our consumption of energy? For many Canadians, there simply is no alternative to their current lifestyles. You can tax my ability to drive my car, but if you don't give me a good transit system, I have no choice. You can tax my ability to heat my home, but as long as our winters are among the coldest in the world, I have no choice. My consumption will not change in any material way without alternatives available.
This tax is just another way to transfer wealth from rural or suburban Canadians, who have no choice but to consume energy, to city dwellers.
If you're serious about controlling emmissions, then try fixing the real underlying problem--overpopulation. Until you fix that, all the energy conservation we do won't mean a damn thing.
Dave,
I would have loved nothing more than to attack the idea of a carbon tax as well, but we both know the conservatives gave up that fight without even starting it. They have given legitimacy to the 'science' of global warming by paying it lip service. Liberal spinmasters could easily turn any direct attack on the carbon tax plan as an attack on 'the science of global warming'. Hence, to attack the idea now would be suicidal. Better to attack what matters: our quality of life is at stake if we adopt Dion's plan.
Post a Comment