Spring has sprung! The grass is riz! I wonder when the election is?
Conservatives here in Newmarket-Aurora are itching for an election call. Too bad there isn't going to be one. Not this spring, not this year. It simply isn't in the cards, and nothing so far has convinced me otherwise.
Conventional wisdom among Conservatives in this riding was that the government would fall over the budget. But I just couldn't see it happening. If the Conservatives weren't in majority territory by budget time, they could always use their secret weapon: the fiscal imbalance. Gilles Duceppe all but handed it to the Conservatives on a silver platter last year when the Bloc supported the first Conservative budget on the government's promise to fix the fiscal imbalance in 2007. "The real budget will be next year, not this year," Duceppe said to reporters in foyer of the House of Commons last year. Conservatives knew that if there was no guaranteed majority on the horizon all they had to do to win Bloc support was make good on the fiscal imbalance. Winning Bloc support guaranteed passage of the budget.
As things stand now, the Liberals, the Bloc, and the NDP will do everything in their power to avoid an election. Here's why:
First: regardless of the fact that national polls are putting the Conservatives on the cusp of the magic "40" the reality is that voter intentions are much too volatile at this time. If an election were called today evidence suggests that the results would be similar to what we have now. This is in spite of Dion's terrible leadership numbers. The slightest misstep in Ontario could backfire horrendously on the Conservatives and send their popularity numbers down the toilet, while the Liberals will be given a fair amount of latitude. Harper already knows the public can change their minds in an instant, and the risk to his party's position is greater than the benefit of a few more seats.
In the minds of voters, things are getting done, which is more than they're used to, and there is no appetite among the electorate for a federal election. So as much as the Conservatives are working toward a majority in the polls (as evidenced by the budget and the flurry of announcements since Christmas), the likelihood of an election call simply because there is a possible majority in the offing seems remote. Even if a majority was likely, it is doubtful that the Conservatives could maintain those numbers in campaign mode. They need an issue of significance to campaign on. An electoral question is required.
Harper will not have forgotten how quickly his popularity evaporated when he openly mused about a majority during the 2004 campaign. He is also is aware of the devastation to the Liberal Party in Ontario after an election was called early simply because premier David Peterson wanted to capitalize on favourable polling numbers.
Second: Harper has repeatedly said, and continues to say, that he will not engineer the government's demise, that he wants to continue to govern and that there is still lots of work to do. To then knowingly trigger an election will damage his credibility to the point that his majority could disappear easily. The aforementioned volatility in voter intentions do not support the idea that Harper will engineer his own defeat.
Third: Stephane Dion is the weakest leader the Liberals have had in recent memory. Nothing short of a miracle will change this. And much like the Sponsorship Scandal, Dion is a gift that keeps on giving. With Liberal veterans "retiring" like rats from a sinking ship, the best possible thing for the Conservatives is for Dion to remain leader of the Liberal Party of Canada. Unless Dion steps down out of the blue, they will need an election before they can choose a new leader. For this reason, the Conservatives will do everything possible to prevent the Liberals from falling on their own swords, and since the Liberals can't bring the government down on their own, they need the help of all three opposition parties.
Which brings me to the fourth reason there won't be an election this year: neither the Bloc, nor the NDP can afford an election.
After the astounding success of the ADQ in the Quebec election the Bloc is no position to test voter intentions. They are closely tied to the Parti Quebcois, so much so they are considered one in the same in some quarters. And their main raison d'etre, separatism, is no longer the driving force behind Quebec politics, leaving them in the position of being irrelevant to the average voter. Not at all conducive to electoral victory.
The NDP cannot afford to test voter intentions either given the recent popularity of the Green Party and the fact that strategic voting among the left could weaken their party further. Jamie Heath, a former communications director for the NDP recently published a book suggesting the Left is in danger of suffering the same disease that gripped conservatives for more than a decade; vote splitting. Let's also not forget that Jack Layton has made a public plea to cease and desist all this electioneering, a sure sign that he wants to avoid an election.
In fact, Layton has a particular interest in seeing Parliament work because he has a vested interest in getting the revamped Clean Air Act passed.
To further add to Jack Layton's troubles, Elizabeth May has made it clear that she supports parking votes with the Liberal party for no other reason than to defeat Harper. This will complicate life immensely for Layton because he cannot afford to lose any support, which is why he issued his plea on Thursday. All in all, not a good picture for the opposition.
For all of Dion's blustering that "Harper is trying to force an election", and that "the Liberal Party of Canada will be ready", they are woefully unprepared. While they are feverishly trying to get candidates nominated in all 308 ridings, they still have no visible platform or policy. They must do more than offer the "environment," or Kyoto.
What do the Liberals want to accomplish as government? What have they done to earn votes? All they have been able to do is whine that Stephen Harper is a bully. Hardly enough to win the hearts and minds of the people. Not at all enough to raise the Liberals out of the electoral gutter.
Too much credence has been given to the theory that the government could fall over the revised Clean Air Act. It is pretty clear that all three opposition parties will support it, so how could the government fall, even if they make it a confidence motion? Unless I am unaware of some obscure constitutional edict that says the government could fall on the passage of a bill, I don't see how this could trigger an election. If the amendments to the bill are as unpalatable as they seem, I would think that the Conservatives will let the bill die on the order paper without ever introducing it.
There is also speculation that the government will fall over several bills (C-10, C-27, C-35) to tackle gun crime and sentencing, but the reality is the opposition will have to soften their stance and work with the government in order to avoid facing voters.
Bottom line: no election.
1 comment:
Kirk,
I agree with your reasoning. I don't see an election anytime soon.
I think it's actually the media and the Liberals that like to drag the election speculation on. They figure that if they keep repeating over and over that Harper wants an election, when the election finally does come (whether it was forced by Harper or not), they want the public to blame him for causing it.
On the bright side... if election speculation is all anyone has to complain about, then Harper must be doing a great job!
Post a Comment