One of the surest signs that the Liberal Party is in big trouble is when a star candidate like Bob Rae decides to run in one of the country's safest ridings. Rae, who after a decade hiatus from politics should be preparing for a high profile battle is instead yawning his way to the next election. He recently secured the nomination for the riding of Toronto-centre having defeated political hopeful and newcomer Meredith Cartwright. Toronto Centre is Bill Graham's seat, the former interim leader. In the 2006 election, he won with more than 52% of the vote, defeating his NDP opponent by a margin of more than 15,000 votes. Why didn't Rae choose a riding where the Conservatives won by a narrow margin? The former Premier of Ontario is a seasoned campaigner, having fought several elections. Surely he's confident he could take a riding currently held by a rookie Conservative.
There are any number of ridings outside the GTA that could be taken from the Conservatives if given the right candidate. Ridings like Ancaster-Dundas-Flamboraugh-Westdale, Barrie, Burlington, Hamilton East-Stoney Creek, Hamilton Mountain, Peterborough, and even Finance Minister's Whitby-Oshawa riding are all potential targets. An aggressive Liberal Party would have no compunction putting a battle ready candidate into those ridings. Today's Liberal Party, however, is meek, content to whine from the sidelines.
Rae's choice to run in Toronto-Centre may be a sign that the LIberals are bracing themselves for a slaughter at the polls. It may be a sign that Rae, like the Liberal Party of Canada, is tired, and unable to mount a fiery campaign of ideas. It may also be a sign that Dion's own strength within the party is limp.
Why has Dion allowed insta-Liberal Bob Rae to pick fortress Toronto to run in, but demand that heir-apparent Justin Trudeau "cut his teeth" in Papineau? Yes, Papineau has been a Liberal stronghold since 1953, but in 2004 the BQ only narrowly lost to Pierre Pettigrew (Minister of Foreign Affairs under Paul Martin). In 2006 the riding went to the Bloc Quebcois, ending a 50 year Liberal reign. If Trudeau wins the nomination, he has a pretty good chance of winning the riding back for the Liberals in the next election. But why must young Trudeau earn his stripes, yet Rae sleepwalk to the House of Commons?
To a Liberal, there's nothing worse than an instal-Liberal looking for an easy ride. Long time Liberals with battle scars must be hot under the collar to know that Bob Rae, a former NDP Premier and NDP Party Leader can just waltz into one of Toronto's safest ridings knock off a would be female candidate that fits one of Dion's highest profile promises: to have 33% female candidates. It is also perhaps a sign of Dion's personal weakness within his own party. Under Dion's decree that 33% of candidates be female, political hopeful Meredith Cartwright should have had the benefit of seeking the Dion's pledge to meet 33% female content. Instead, he allowed Rae to use his vast political weight to defeat an able bodied female with the drive and resources to fight a nomination. Now, Dion will be in the position of having to "select" another perhaps less able female in another riding.
Another questionable choice is Martha Hall Findlay's decision to run in Willodale. Another easy win for a Liberal. Martha Hall Findlay is articulate, savvy, and a good choice to win a hotly contested riding. After coming so close to beating Belinda Stronach in 2004, it would be understandable if she didn't want a fight, but she's a candidate capable of defeating Conservatives on their own ground. Why not use that to win more seats? Now that Stronach has quit, you have to wonder why Martha Hall Findlay wasn't given the opportunity to go after the Newmarket-Aurora nomination.
Now Dion has said he won't run a candidate in Peter MacKay's riding so the Green Party leader Elizabeth May can run uncontested. Liberals have run third in this riding for the last two elections. This must upset Jack Layton to no end because the NDP are gaining ground in that riding. In 2006, they came within 8 percentage points of unseating MacKay.
It's clear that while veteran MPs retire, the party is more interested in closing ranks and circling the wagons. Better to fight from a position of strength than take unecessary risks. But that strategy was decided after Dion was chosen as leader. Liberals may not be so confident that their party can make gains. Which is why they need to solidify their policy positions and start attacking the government with more than just "Harper is a bully", or that "Harper is a climate-change denier". It sounds more like whining.
It seems that Dion is behaving in a reactionary manner rather than on a pre-defined strategy. He seems to stumbling his way through willy-nilly, not charting a course. What will he do next?
3 comments:
If enough Liberals park their vote with the NDP, then Mackay could very well lose his seat.
The NDP's vote in Central Nova was mostly due to a strong local candidate who has since moved to Toronto and is not running again. Elizabeth May is the clear alternative to Mackay. Voters will see that and support her, just as they did in London North Centre when she out-polled the NDP by almost 100%.
Chris,
Good luck in Toronto Centre. Good luck against Bob!
The move makes more sense now that you've shed some light on the NDP candidate. Still, some NDP are not fans of the Greens, and Liberal voters are not guaranteed to throw their support behind May.
Still, this will be an interesting riding to watch.
Thanks for letting us know!
Post a Comment