Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Our Little Mosque in Newmarket

Dear Anonymous,

Once again thanks for reading my blog.

At the time I wrote my reply to your original questions the facts as I understood them were as follows:

1. The Town of Newmarket has approved a plan to convert a house into a Mosque. From my understanding Zafar Bangash submitted a plan to the town and it was approved. The Mayor says this is strictly a planning issue.
2. The Era Banner in an editorial says the town failed to have hearings into the proposal.
3. Town council seems to have confirmed this editorial by replying that they didn't think citizens would care or oppose the mosque.
4. The Town appears to have an interest in the mosque because it was be a "first" for Newmarket.
5. In a recent letter to the editor, an individual wrote that the town had denied a request to rezone the same property to another religious group, which raises questions over why one religious group would receive approval over another.
6. To further complicate the matter, the mosque will be run/administered by a controversial Imam.

These were the facts prevailing at the time of my reply. Since then, I have read Saturday's Era Banner and some further facts have come to light.

1. That the other religious group that had originally applied to use the site have apparently not followed through with the paperwork, and, therefore, there appears to be no "political interference" in the zoning system.
2. I also now have learned that there are only 200 or so Muslims in the area that can be considered as potential patrons of the mosque. This is important when compared to the 300 who showed up at town council to oppose the mosque.

These are the facts as I have come to know them. If there is any other pertinent information that you might be able to provide I would be happy to learn it.

Anonymous, I know exactly what the controversy is about. It's about whether or not we are willing to allow a religious leader like Zafar Bangash into our community despite the fact that we support freedom of speech. It's about the greater problem that seems to be growing in this country and in countries around the world. In Herouxville, in England, and other European countries there is a growing discontentment with the beliefs and influence Islamist leaders have over other muslims.

However, I won't indulge in any knee-jerk reactions without having all the facts at hand. Certainly any reasonable person would expect me to get all the facts on an issue before stating a "position" or making a stand. Is this not true?

As of right now, however, I still have questions. For instance, if the approval of the mosque is purely a "zoning", or "planning" issue as the mayor suggests, why would the people show up at council to oppose the mosque? Does the town have the authority to deny a proposal because of the political views of the applicant? If so, would we be leaving ourselves open to an expensive charter challenge? Is that the reason council did not allow hearings?

Furthermore, I would be remiss to comment on the politics of Mr. Bangash without doing my own due diligence. Relying on editorials and guest columns in the Era Banner isn't what I consider to be thorough research. I had only a vague interest in the story to begin with. But since you questioned me about it I took some time to read more on the issue. But even after learning more, I still don't have enough information to take a position.

Anonymous, you have asked that if I don't have a position on this particular issue, what is it that I want to accomplish in Ottawa? My website and my blog entries are filled with the answers to that question. I am committed to taking the voices of the people to Ottawa. I'm committed to fighting for the middle class. I'm committed to instituting my own personal pledge of accountability that will give the people of Newmarket-Aurora a mechanism to hold me directly accountable should I not fulfill the commitments I make. I'm committed to providing as many avenues as technically possible for the people to communicate with me.

I have many times throughout my blog entries made statements about my positions. As I explore new topics readers will get to know much more. But I won't attempt to talk about issues without first knowing all the angles. And as you say, the mosque issue is a local one.

You have stated that you "can agree with most" of Lois Brown's views. Which views belonging to Lois Brown do you agree with? I personally cannot find any information about her position on anything whatsoever. You admit she "would probably [be] a very ineffective MP" yet you seem content to choose her anyway. Why?

You are right when you say people are tired of career politicians and that they "want someone with character that will stand up when it's time to take a stand" yet are happy to support Lois Brown without conditions, without qualification. Is she not willing to go on the record? If not, why? If not, why is Lois Brown the best choice? Was Lois Brown at the council meeting?

We demand our politicians have ideas. We say that it's time to say goodbye to "grin and grip photo-op" politicians yet we continue to elect exactly that kind of politician. When will our desire for a different politician result in the election of one?

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Let's try to avoid slinging a bit of mud in the nomination campaign, shall we?

Robert Otto said...

Anonymous said ... "let's try to avoid slinging a bit of mud in the nomination campaign, shall we?"

Curious. I have read all of Kirk's Blogs pertaining to Lois Brown's ONCE AGAIN Conservative nomination bid for Newmarket/Aurora (it's becoming as predictable as ground hog day) .... and I can't seem to find any mud which has been flung. Perhaps you could show us a scoop or two so that we would know what it looks like.

As a matter of fact, the only mud which I find is caked to your own slingshot. Here are excerpts from your recent comment posts to Kirk's Blog;

(1) "Lois Brown failed to bring her spine with her last night, and consequently lost a lot of respect from her core supporters." posted 2/11/2007

(2) "Lois is quite a force to be reckoned with, at least among Conservatives." posted 2/12/2007

(3) "I can agree with most of her views, but she succumbs to political correctness and tries to steer clear of controversy. Unfortunately this behaviour would probably make her a very ineffective M.P." posted 2/12/2007

(4) "People are tired of career politicians. They want someone with character that will stand up when it's time to take a stand. For now the best choice is still Lois."

So let me understand you ... Lois has lost her spine before ... which cost her a lot of respect ... but she's still a force to be reckoned with among Conservatives ... although she succumbs to political correctness and tries to steer clear of controversy ... which will probably make her an ineffective M.P ...but since people want someone with character that will stand up when it's time to take a stand ... Lois, despite having no spine, a focus on political correctness and wanting to avoid controversy , for now is the best choice! Did I get that right?

Anonymous ... with looney Liberal logic like that ... are you in fact Belinduh Stronach?

Way to go slagging your own candidate Jack!

By the way, if you are looking to avoid mudslinging pertaining to Lois, then please do not visit my Blog; cantankerousconservative.blogspot.com There are only two posts so far but I'm starting to feel creative.

Have an anonymous day!

Kirk West said...

Robert Otto,

Thank you very much for your comments and your kind words on Cantankerous Conservative


Anonymous,

For an excellent analysis of the Mosque issue, please visit Darryl Wolk Politics.

He goes beyond the rhetoric and hype, bringing to light some facts that were not available to the readers of the Era Banner. His analysis reinforces my original position, which was, as you know, to not take a position until I had all the facts.

Kirk West said...

Sorry, I messed up the links. Here they are:

The Cantankerous Conservative

Darryl Wolk Politics

Art2Go said...

"Our Little Mosque in Newmarket"
this political "HOT POTATOE"
just won't go away!, I wondered why you would change the subject to Lois Brown, same old same ... blah blah. That's a topic that could warrant it's own blog.

Surly you must have a opinion on the Mosque controversy in Newmarket. especially since so much has happened since, ie. Protesters get searched @ the Best Western, (yesterday's Era).

And how about the ToryBlogs top topic today:
One in Ten Canadian Muslims endorse beheading PM

I couldn't care less about a Mosque in Newmarket, but I do Care about: "the alarming number of Canadian Muslims who espouse a very extremist opinion!"

There is no shortage of information,(good & bad), on the internet about Western Muslums, the ICIT and Zafar Bangash & his views, "Power: the neglected dimension of the Seerah"

Anyway ... I joined the Conservative party to be able to vote in the upcoming candidates nomination. I have yet to get a card or receipt or even an invitation to the party!

What's happening Kirk?
The upcoming Tory budget might trigger an election, and what about the Anti-terror provisons struck DOWN!

gday ..?
Doug